Why are insurance prices so drastically different between insurance companies?

Why are insurance prices so drastically different between insurance companies?

I called 4 or 5 insurance companies today, hoping to set up my own personal auto insurance for the first time. I'-m a 17 year old male and have been involved in an accident for which I was at fault, so I expected premiums to be extremely high. I called TD meloche monnex, the cooperators, Allstate and Brokerlink. I requested the most basic insurance from each for my 2002 Camry LE. Allstate had the cheapest rate by almost 700 dollars a year. The cooperators were asking for more then 1000 dollars annually compared to them. Generally, my decision would be easy, but the catch was that Allstate wouldn'-t set up a payment plan for me. I would have one payment of 1676. An I being ripped off? Or is Allstate really just that much better? I requested the most basic coverage from each, so is the most basic coverage from Allstate the same as the most basic coverage from other companies? Thanks for any imput!!!


A common problem encountered when getting auto quotes (particularly online) is that many aggregator sites give you an estimate of what an insurer might charge you. And I say "might" because for the purposes of a quote they often will not run underwriting reports such as a credit score, a MVR (a record of tickets and accidents) or a CLUE report about previous losses. These reports cost money so they are not ordered just to give you a quote.When you actually apply for coverage (when they know you're a customer) they will complete the underwriting by ordering the reports. So depending upon what shows up your final quote might be quite different than your original quote.Source(s):...



Popular Q&A

Can the auto insurance company pay me directly for my medical expenses or do they have to pay the doctor?
Your medical insurance provider will collect from the insurance company of the driver who caused your injuries. This process is called subrogation. It is standard practice throughout the US.You are not entitled to dual benefit from your injuries. Go ahead and consult an attorney -- he or...

Under-aged DWI charge dropped, still affect insurance?
Your insurance can only be increased for "moving violations" for which you are convicted. Since you were not convicted they cannot surcharge your policy. Also fyi in the majority of states surcharges only apply for 3 years not 5 years.However, one piece of unsolicited advice--I realize that...

Do you need a drivers license to get auto insurance in Montana?
Well duh. Of course you need a drivers license to get auto insurance.

How does a traffic ticket, first offense, impact the cost of auto insurance in dollars or percentage?
It depends on the company and its policies. Insurers don't routinely check your record on renewal because of the cost of doing it, but they will check at some point and see it. What effect it has on your rates is up to the company.

How much $ does Geico Auto Insurance cover for car theft?
If you have comprehensive insurance, they will cover up to the current market value (actual cash value) of the vehicle. Minus your deductible.