Why are NYS auto insurance rates so high?

Why are NYS auto insurance rates so high?

I live in NYC, and have taken over my late Dad'-s auto insurance. I was looking up quotes from other insurance companies (currently have Geico), and all the quotes are the same as I pay now, or more. My own license is clean, no accidents, violations, tickets, etc. I just want to know why NYS auto insurance rates are so high?


First, it is not all of NYS, it is NYC specifically. Insurance rates are much lower upstate.Second, the reason is because NYC has many more car thieves that other cities, many more accidents than other cities, and more fraud than most places.


New York State is divided into approximately 70 rating territories to reflect differences in claim costs in those territories. Traffic patterns, population demographics, and the cost of goods and services contribute to insurance cost variations. You are allowed one free guess as to where the highest rated territory is.Source(s):...


rates are high because people have lots of accidents there - everyone's rates in the same area are affected by that fact - your personal driving record is only one factor in the calculationnew cars cost more to insure than old cars - if you r car has a loan on it, you will be required to have collision, which increases the cost, plus newer cars are more expensive, so it costs more to fix them and insure them it's not difficult to understand


There are a bunch of reasons, including but not limited to the regulations the insurance department makes the insurance companies follow. NYS has an insolvency fund which requires heavy payments from any carriers who write policies in NY. They also have a "full tort" system and more lawyers per capita than most states (higher claim payouts). Lastly, NY has the second highest rate of fraud, per capita - more than double California, which has the third highest rate of fraud.Oh, I forgot to add this. NY uses credit scores as a rating factor. If your dad's credit score was significantly better than yours, that would also be reflected in the rates. It's not unexpected, either - most likley dad has his house paid for, and you have a massive mortgage.



Popular Q&A

What type of car insurance should I get in Michigan?
Michigan is a wierd state for insurance. If your car is worth anything, you will have to have physical damage coverage. Reason: If you are in an accident, the most you can collect is $500.00 from the other insurance company ( it is called a mini tort) unless you ae legally parked at the...

I rented a Uhaul truck and damaged my aunts car, i purchased the full coverage, will uhaul cover damages?
Yes they should cover..... but..... Did you read and follow the "what to do If I have an accident" part of the insurance instructions? Did you notify Uhaul? They can't pay, if they don't know about the accident.You "basically" rented a Uhaul eh? Is that different from just plain renting...

What computer skills or knowledge do I need to get a job working at home?
I've worked (at home) for Arise for the past 17 months. To my knowledge, they are the leader in home-based work. They are a reputable company in business for 10 years and growing to Europe. They have contracts with large corporations, such as, Disney, AAA, Sears, Carnival Cruise Lines, Virgin...

Would filing a personal bankruptcy keep me from getting a license to sell, auto life and home insurance?
No. Bankruptcy laws were designed to PROTECT you, and give you a second chance.From a credit standpoint, a bankruptcy may be viewed as a "black mark" on your credit record, but it does NOT mean you are a bad person or dishonest, etc. It just means you got in too deep at some point, and needed...

Where can I get free legal advice about small claims auto insurance SR22 coverage?
You can get plenty of free legal advice right here on Yahoo! Answers, but remember...Free Legal Advice is worth exactly what you paid for it.