Why are some insurance companys rates so much higher then others?

Why are some insurance companys rates so much higher then others?

Isn'-t there a risk "-guide"- insurance company'-s use? shouldn'-t that be the same or similar for all Insurance company'-s?I ask because I switched insurance company'-s and saved $300 for a 6 month policy. That seems to be a bit excessive to be "-off"- by that much.


Unless you live in a state like NY that sets the rates for health insurance, or in a state like MA, that until recently, set the rates for auto insurance, each insurance company can set their OWN rates. Some companies will "target" youthful operators with clean records, and have slightly lower rates there. Some will target the three car family with no teens, some will target homeowners, etc. There's a HUGE variety of difference in appetite for what a company wants to write - and, it can change from year to year!That's why shopping around, is the ONLY way to find out how good your rate actually is. It's also why most financial advisors (and honest agents) recommend shopping around at least once every three years.FWIW, I saved 50% on my auto insurance by switching carriers in December - $1200. And that's "apples to apples" coverage.


All companies have to submit their rates for approvals in each of the states they do business. When the insurance companies figure their rates they have to take into consideration all of their expenses and adjust their rates to cover those expenses plus the assumed amount in claims they will have. The states highly regulate how much an insurance company can charge, that being said you have to look at what the insurance companies pay for.Every company pays for different things and different amounts. Towing, Theft of items from the vehicle and so on so forth. Another thing you can look at is different companies are going to rate things differently, such as certain types of cars are going to be treated differently by different companies.Hope that helps.


I think that there is probably a $300 difference just from the differences in how much they spend on paying for insurance agents and television ads. Or, maybe not. Geico and Progressive seem to do the most advertising, but they don't have the highest prices.



Popular Q&A

Do you have to have a vehicle to get an auto insurance quote?
The type or car--sedan, coupe, SUV, convertible--can make a difference in the cost to insure, especially if you need to carry comp/collision on it. If you just want quotes on public liability/medical/UM/UIM, that doesn't generally make a difference. Just plug in a year, make and model similar...

Funny Questions To Ponder...?
Great List. Because I'm bored, I'm going to answer them even though they are rhetorical:Why doesn't McDonald's sell hotdogs?Its a burger joint. Why doesn't Taco Bell sell burgers?At a movie theater which arm rest is yours?Both!What is Satan's last name?Satan-Sataniel, in Christianity as Lucifer...

Any ideas how to open a insurance agency in NC?
Depending on your state's specific requirements, you will probably at least need your P & C (property & casualty) license as an agent & a separate P & C license as a broker if you want to write excess or surplus markets (this license also usually requires a bond). Many states will also require...

What are some discounts that many auto insurance companies offer that might help save some money?
Depends on the company and the state that you live in. Auto insurance is regulated by each state so it can differ from state to state.Some companies might offer:-Good student discount (if you have a B or better average, so 3.0 or higher)-Driver Training discount (if you got your drivers license...

Does anyone know where I can find a list of average auto insurance rates by vehicle?
Welcome to the club! We have tried a few and changed to one that saved us over $1500.00 per year. We tried all the others and got so many quotas it made our head spin. So for the last 5 years we have been with AARP Hartford Ins. We have two boys on the policy, one 21 and the other is 17...